2011 Virginia NSA Umpire Evaluation Analysis

  • 12 categories to measure umpire proficiency
  • Updates made as necessary to maintain focus
  • Umpires, coaches, players: send us your inputs
    • What makes a remarkable umpire? Remarkably good or bad?
       
  • Umpire Evaluation Score Card click here 

Email comments to:  Ron Zuhl    Jim Finch

                    

       .667 is a decent batting average, but as shown in the photos below,
 2 for 3 isn't quite good enough when it comes to umpire position and mechanics.
 

What's Wrong with this Picture?
(besides the swing and a miss)

Play at 3rd
An Ump Out from Behind the Plate!!!
(this rare (?) photo worth millions)

Getting the Best Angle for Throw at 1st
 and Play at Home
(catcher in good position to watch)

 

Subject: NSA Umpire Evaluation Analysis
To: All Virginia NSA Umpires
From: Jim Finch, Fastpitch UIC
Ron Zuhl, State Slowpitch UIC


Gentlemen:

The Umpire Evaluation form that I will be using has a total of twelve categories in which you will be measured. What you will find here is an explanation of what I will be looking for or considering for each of those categories. The explanations are short but should be fairly clear in meaning.

1. DRESS - Proper NSA Official uniform

2. PROMPTNESS - Arrive prior to the first scheduled game 30 minutes before start time

3. COMMAND OF THE GAME - Do you have the respect of the players? Do you keep the game moving? Do you enforce the rules, including the hard calls?

4. HUSTLE - Are you in the proper position for the situation, including behind the plate and on the bases? Do you keep moving so that the game is not waiting on you?

5. BALLS & STRIKES – Do you know the strike zone and let the teams know what you called? Do you work the corners?

6. CONSISTENCY - In everything you do: strike zone, getting in position, verbal skills, mechanics, communication, and relating with the players and coaches.

7. OVERALL ATTITUDE - You are there for the benefit of the teams. What is your demeanor on the field? What are your mannerisms? How do you communicate with the players? Does your expression say how you feel?

8. PROFESSIONALISM - How do you react to pressure? Do you keep your composure in tough situations. Poise. What is your presence when entering and leaving the field? Do you cooperate with your UIC?

9. HANDLES RESPONSIBILITY – Do you accept your assignment? Do you use good judgement?

10. GENERAL APPEARANCE - Is your uniform clean? Are you neat and clean shaven? Shoes shined? Do you make an effort to stay physically able to perform and excel as an umpire?

11. MECHANICS - Positioning behind the plate or on the bases: are you getting the best angle to make the call? Do you use proper arm signals and vocal signals so that the teams know what the call was? Are you consistent with your calls? Where are you between innings?

12. OVERALL KNOWLEDGE OF THE RULES - Do you know what they are? As they apply to the situation? How do you apply them? Do you make the tough call?

All of these categories make up the necessary ingredients for being a good umpire. If you will review each one and apply them to how you officiate, and keep in mind what changes you need to make – you are well on your way to being a good umpire. Please give thought to each area and if you have questions of what is expected, please ask. This evaluation is for the purposes of helping each of you to be the best umpire you can be. I will sit and discuss with you the results of the evaluation as well as ideas and/or suggestions for improving yourself.

The goal is to have consistency among our umpires, to build a group comradery, and to provide the best environment in which we can enjoy what we like to do – CALL SOFTBALL!

Sincerely,

Ron Zuhl   Virginia NSA Slowpitch Umpire in Chief

Jim Finch  Virginia  NSA Fastpitch Umpire in Chief